Annie and Alonzo Hartman and their Historic Gunnison Home

May 4, 2025 | History

Header Logo Hartman Castle Preservation

Written by Hartman Castle Preservation

May 4, 2025

Who are Annie and Alonzo Hartman?

Two of Gunnison’s early white settlers, Alonzo and Annie Haigler Hartman, left a compelling legacy. Alonzo arrived in the valley as a U.S. military agent and cowboy, tasked with keeping livestock alive through the Gunnison winters to feed the Ute people, who had been displaced from their hunting grounds and relocated to the Western Slope. When the discovery of gold and silver led to further Ute relocation and opened the area to white settlement, Alonzo played a key role in founding the city of Gunnison and building the irrigation ditches that beautified it. He quickly became an influential community leader and businessman.
A photo of Annie and Alonzo Hartman
Wedding photo of Alonzo & Annie Hartman
Colorized images of Annie and Alonzo Hartman side by side, showing them as middle-aged adults with neutral expressions looking toward the viewer.

Colorized image of Annie and Alonzo Hartman, courtesy of Hartman Castle Preservation Board Member, Pam Williams.

Annie, a socialite, artist, philanthropist, teacher, and community activist, was deeply involved in charity work and the fight for women’s rights. She also often partnered with Alonzo in his business ventures. Both Annie and Alonzo supported and often advocated for people from backgrounds and cultures different from their own. In Alonzo’s biography, he mentions his friendship with Chief Ouray of the Ute, writing “he and I became fast friends” and saying, “I never knew [the Ute] of causing the white man trouble unless there was just cause.” 

Later in his biography, Alonzo casually mentions “the party of gypsies” they would welcome to camp on their land every Spring—and during a time when cities were issuing proclamations banning such groups. Historic newspaper clippings also mention Annie among a small group of Gunnison women who ensured “Aunt” Susan, a freed slave and beloved Gunnison community member, had a proper burial site upon her passing. By many accounts, the Hartmans were known to spread love to all, regardless of their backgrounds.

While it would be impossible to list all the ways the Hartmans contributed to Gunnison—both during their lifetimes and through their lasting impact—one treasure stands above the rest: Hartman Castle.

Colorized image of the Hartman Castle in Gunnison, Colorado from the front with green trees and blue skies surrounding the brown brick, Victorian home.

Colorized image of Hartman Castle, courtesy of Hartman Castle Preservation Board Member, Pam Williams.

The Hartman Castle

The home itself holds profound significance. Built in the 1890s from plans Annie developed with her minister, the Castle is a stunning example of Victorian-era design, blending Queen Anne and Gothic styles. It remains an unaltered time capsule, showcasing classical architectural features, many of which were acquired at the 1893 Chicago World’s Fair. The Castle hosted many significant early Gunnison events and today offers visitors a vivid glimpse into upper-middle-class and ranch life on the Western frontier.

Thanks to Annie and Alonzo’s enduring leadership and characters, the Hartman Castle Preservation Corporation now has the rare opportunity to showcase not only the Castle but also the broader history of the Western Slope, including cattle ranching, boom and bust mining economies, resiliency and hope, the contributions of Gunnison’s Black community, Native American history in Colorado, and the advancement of women’s rights.

We hope you’ll join us as we work to restore and preserve the magic of Hartman Castle, including the many stories both the Castle and the land it sits on have yet to tell. Get involved by volunteering or donating today!

Related Articles

Related